linked in facebook twitter rss

  • Interbrand
  • Brandchannel

your chance!
your chance!
Also of Interest...
     
  Vincent Grimaldi iDrive to iPhone, the Next Big Thing in Life: Realizing the potential of your consumer brand
by Vincent Grimaldi de Puget
January 1, 2007

Not long ago, the PR war between Virgin Atlantic and British Airways reached new heights when BA-sponsored London Eye, a Ferris-like observation wheel, failed to be erected on its first attempt. At the news, Virgin promptly flew a blimp over the City of London that read: "BA can't get it up." Increasingly the battlefield is expanding to the entire globe; strong brands—e.g., those deeply anchored in a lifestyle—have proven to be critical engines driving growth strategies. Virgin comes to mind with its rocking attitude, but Ford and Apple also superbly illustrate where such potential lies.

At a time where the American concept of middle class is yielding to myriad, borderless segments, the Ford brand displays considerable untapped potential with its "blue-collar strength" positioning. Despite Ford Motor Company's current troubles, its F-Series line of trucks remains among the best-selling vehicles in the world…available in large (F-1), XL (F-2), and XXL (F-3) sizes. To its fan base in the American heartland, the justification for buying the truck is simple: it's tough—Ford Tough!

 
 

The Ford brand is a goldmine: a whole lineup, from toolboxes to lawn mowers, could fit within the "Tough" positioning. Surprisingly, though, the diehard fan wearing an oval-shaped Ford belt buckle cannot buy products connoting "toughness" outside the light-truck product line, and no car, minivan, or any other Ford-branded offering makes the "Tough" promise.

Actually, few of the most popular car brands—including Beetle, Golf, Corvette, and Mustang—have ventured outside the boundaries of the automotive industry at all. All of them sell branded key holders and golf balls, but only luxury makes, such as Ferrari, have genuinely attempted to stretch their brands into non-auto products, like gold watches and fountain pens sold through separate distribution channels. Among the notable mass-market exceptions is Peugeot, which has stretched the brand on nearly all its individual vehicles: cars, motorbikes, and bicycles. There is little doubt that a line of Peugeot sports shoes, with or without wheels, would be an exciting way to attract kids and other hard-to-reach demographics.

Ford and GM did, in fact, launch lines of branded credit cards. They should have been a hit, but they probably suffered from the manufacturers' lack of experience with brand management in the 1990s. The carmakers' credit cards were generally considered as (expensive) marketing programs rather than new growth areas. At the time, many carmakers would have argued (and rightly so in such vertical industries) that pushing credit cards, fountain pens, and other consumer goods is not part of their core business.

That is, however, if you feel that their business is manufacturing vehicles. But what if we consider that the strongest asset that those companies have is in their brand? Many people from various industries and countries have wondered the same question in their respective fields.

Across the pond, Richard Branson, with a natural instinct for branding and lateral thinking, has been proactive in stretching his music label into airlines, beverages, credit cards, and phone-carrier brands.

A longtime music producer, Sir Richard's resume might hardly show any expertise in telephony, but the British entrepreneur does know a thing or two about pleasing his customers.

Virgin Mobile actually does not operate a telephony infrastructure. It is a mobile virtual network operator (MVNO), which leases network capacity at a wholesale rate to existing operators. In sum, Virgin leverages the power of its brand to reach segments, such as the youth market, more effectively than the traditional telcos, while using a third-party infrastructure like that of T-Mobile.

In a business model that now fits many consumer product and service industries, even a car could conceivably be called Virgin while being designed by Porsche in Germany and assembled on the spare capacity of General Motors in Detroit or the Nanjing Automobile Group in China (and perhaps never need an oil change!).

Others, such as the Carphone Warehouse, have also ventured into operating an MVNO. With more than 1,400 stores in Europe, Carphone Warehouse leverages its retail network rather than its brand. In the UK it leases capacity from, again, T-Mobile. But in France, Carphone Warehouse has pooled forces with Virgin. The joint venture operates in that market under the sexier Virgin Mobile brand, using the Orange network, and plans to attract 1 million customers within the next three years. The new phone plans are distributed through almost 1,000 points of sale, which include Phone House and Virgin Megastore outlets.

There is another star-entrepreneur that has successfully moved his brand out of the box. Three decades after the birth of Apple, the iPod is in nearly every purse and pants pocket. However, cell phones are now increasingly competing with dedicated MP3 players. Rather than playing defense, Apple is in a perfect position to become the next major MVNO, putting a cool iPhone in every hand.

As often in business strategy, there is no one-size-fits-all approach, and Apple's situation appears different from that of Virgin or Carphone Warehouse.

Today, Apple does not make phones but—in the words of one of its top executives—is not "sitting around doing nothing" about it. Thus, we can speculate that an alliance with Motorola would make sense on paper, as the two firms already collaborated on the Rokr, a Motorola phone compatible with the Apple iTunes online music store. As a product, however, the Rokr suffered from business compromises that turned off customers.

Despite the success of a similar alliance between Sony and Ericsson, Steve Jobs might decide that his quest for perfection precludes any co-branding arrangement. The Apple brand would have to stand on its own, which palmOne (known simply as Palm since July 2005) has shown can be done in the mobile business. Technically, Apple has not only the engineering firepower to develop its proprietary mobile operating system (OS), but it could probably license Symbian, a reliable operating system that beats at the heart of many smartphones.

The rollercoaster history of Microsoft Windows Mobile shows that the path from computer OS to smartphone OS is full of difficulties. Licensing a time-tested OS would thus reduce development time, costs, and headaches for Apple.

The economic models of the expensive iPod and the (seemingly) inexpensive wireless phone are also fundamentally different. Phone manufacturers—e.g., Nokia and Samsung—get their devices heavily subsidized by phone operators that lock customers into 12- or 24-month service contracts and recoup the "discount" over monthly bills. In the past, Apple has collaborated with Cingular, a phone operator, and could do so again. As operators also handle customer service, Steve Jobs may balk at this traditional arrangement, though. It would go against the long-term, 360-degree branding effort rolled out in the media, websites, and stores, with its customer-friendly Genius Bar, a popular support station inside every Apple retail store.

Thus, Apple looks ripe to become the next major MVNO, selling and operating wireless devices—at least virtually.

As in the case of Virgin, Apple's issue is more a business-model challenge than a technical one, although a bad product launch would hurt even Apple. Many still remember the debacle of the Apple Newton, the company's unsuccessful line of personal digital assistants. It is nonetheless a reasonable scenario that presents the benefit of giving the Cupertino-based company full control of its brand.

The convergence of technology is happening in the living room, in the office, and also in the pocket. As such, the iPod has little future if it does not become the platform for all the digital services that people expect on the road: phone, emails, pictures, games, web browsing, in addition to iTunes' music and videos. Henry Ford would have agreed: the iPhone is really the next natural step in Apple's growth strategy.

 
   
   Vincent Grimaldi de Puget is a leading brand strategist. He is a partner at GRIFIN PARTNERS, focusing on capital investing and business restructuring, and a visiting professor at US and European business schools.



 
 commenting closed Add Social Bookmark bookmark  print
 suggest topic  recommend ( 8 )  email

  brandchannel brandspeak archive   2013  |  2012  |  2011  |  2010  |  2009  |  2008  | 2007  |  2006  |  2005  |  2004  |  2003  |  2002  |  2001
 
 
Dec 31, 2007 Batch and Blast Emails: Killing Your Brand and Polluting the Environment -- Sheldon Gilbert
  Why behavioral targeting is a habit to focus on.
   
 
Dec 17, 2007 Brand Differentiation Doesn't Cut It Anymore -- Ted Mininni
  Brands can set themselves apart by looking inward.
   
 
Dec 3, 2007 The Science and Art of Design Architecture -- Leigh Bachman
  Smart designs break the mold, not brand equity.
   
 
Nov 19, 2007 The Big Switch: Brands Follow the Indian Customer Online -- Preeti Chaturvedi
  How does India mesh technology and tradition?
   
 
Nov 5, 2007 Strong Brands Support Strong Reputations -- Debbie Myers
  Healthcare gets the branding bug.
   
 
Oct 22, 2007 Marketing a Franchise Brand -- Karyn Kozo
  The forest and the trees of franchise branding.
   
 
Oct 8, 2007 Don’t Be Shy About Conversational Marketing -- Brian Carpizo
  Getting to know customers can make companies self-aware.
   
 
Sep 24, 2007 Keep Your Brandwagon on Track -- Karl Treacher
  How to balance your brand and the interest of others.
   
 
Sep 10, 2007 The Role of Branding in the Airline Industry -- Lizzy Stallard
  Can branding distinguish airlines from each other?
   
 
Aug 27, 2007 The Greenrush: Eco-branding -- Dr. Arlo Brady
  Does the greenrush mean eco-branding is gold?
   
 
Aug 13, 2007 Connected? -- Abram Sauer
  Can blogging tips result in the tipping point for brands?
   
 
Jul 30, 2007 Phone SPAM? -- Lane Michel
  Is direct advertising on mobile phones a savvy marketing technique or simply SPAM meets cold-calling?
   
 
Jul 16, 2007 The “St. Peter’s” Brand Sparkles While Other Brewers Droop -- Tom Blackett
  Can branding inspire Britain, and the world, to develop a taste for British beer?
   
 
Jul 2, 2007 Rascals Rudiments: Kids Getting Bolder Younger! -- Nic Jones
  Are children truly "older" than they were a generation ago? Not necessarily, but brands should be aware of what today's kids are up to.
   
 
Jun 18, 2007 Slam-Dunk Your Way to Brand Loyalty -- Chrissy Toeplitz
  Using the Internet, a brand can develop a memorable campaign—a "slam dunk"—to attract customers and cultivate loyalty.
   
 
Jun 4, 2007 Five Avoidable Marketing Mistakes When Taking Your Brand Global -- Susanne Evens
  Launching a local brand into a wider marketplace requires several considerations.
   
 
May 21, 2007 Brandjacking -- Ted Mininni
  Brands that ignore Internet-based threats do so at their peril.
   
 
May 7, 2007 The Value of Vertical Search for B2B Marketers -- Jeffrey M. Killeen
  A true vertical search engine is based on three fundamental principles.
   
 
Apr 23, 2007 The Search for Soul -- Bernard Leibov
  Exploring the parallel quests for personal and brand identity through the lens of Buddhist thought.
   
 
Apr 9, 2007 Brand Phobia: How to fight your personal brand demons and win -- Lyn Chamberlin
  Personal branding: less fear and excessive modesty, more self-realization and storytelling.
   
 
Mar 26, 2007 Aston Martin: Stretching 007 to 479 million pounds -- Vincent Grimaldi de Puget
  As Ford sells its Aston Martin brand, what should the new owners do to preserve its equity?
   
 
Mar 12, 2007 Emerging Media: Welcome to the evolution -- Jeff Ramminger
  B2B brands should take advantage of blogs, podcasts, and other Web 2.0 technologies.
   
 
Feb 26, 2007 The 2012 Olympics: Location, location, location -- Tom Blackett
  The 2012 Olympics will be held in London—but where in London? The answer could make a big difference for branding the event and the city.
   
 
Feb 12, 2007 A Look Ahead—Casting Online in 2007 -- Angela Hribar
  The increase in marketing opportunities in 2006 was no anomaly. Brands should continue to fish the online waters to hook new customers.
   
 
Jan 29, 2007 Branding the American Idol Way -- Mary T. Morgan
  What can a hit reality-television show about a singing contest teach us about branding?
   
 
Jan 15, 2007 Old-Fashioned and New Virtues for Global Branding -- Jürgen Häusler
  Successful branding requires bold vision, not caution. (In German.)