2011 Product Placement Awards

rss

brand larceny

Facebook Suffers Guilt By Association

Posted by Anthony Zumpano on October 1, 2009 12:08 PM

Brands with user-generated content have to be on alert for user-generated damage. As Facebook increases its ad partnerships on the way to achieving positive cash flow, some questionable affiliate ads appearing on the site have directed users’ ire at the social networking brand itself.

If you’ve used your Facebook account recently, you may have seen ads for Mylife.com, implying that a young, hot, scantily clad female has been Google-hunting you. But, Forbes reports, the ladies in those photos probably don’t know they’re appearing in those ads.

Worse, the images were likely lifted from a site like Jailbaitgallery.com (the name is literal and the site is NSFW), which consists of personal photos from Facebook and other sources, lifted without permission.

Econsultancy's Meghan Keane notes that “neither Facebook nor MyLife broke any policy with the ads, and this kind of thing is likely to continue to some degree with affiliate advertising.” This doesn’t mean the brands won’t suffer for it, however, and both are already on defense: Facebook notes that users can flag questionable ads, and David Oh, MyLife’s manager of marketing design and development, claims that rogue affiliates won’t get paid for using ads like these.

This only raises questions of true responsibility. Is it enough for brands like these to rely on self-policing users to report brand violations, from Craigslist fraud to Wikipedia vandalism, or must they allocate more of their own time and resources to maintain brand integrity?

Comments

Chris United States says:

I don't know which is more troublesome. The facebook ad's mentioned  in the article above or the "elsewhere on brandchannel" sliding self promotion on the right hand side of the page...........

October 2, 2009 07:16 AM #

Dan Hughes United States says:

I have no idea how jailbait.com is run (no... honestly, i swear ;oD ) but the bigger issue is "legitimate" sharing sites. There are literally tens of thousands of photos on sites like Fickr, posted without any copyright restrictions. While these images may not have any obvious financial value, site owners have to do more to educate users as to what "sharing" really means.

October 2, 2009 07:58 AM #

roberto United States says:

Don't most sites have "elsewhere on this site" sort of ads...? And if you're on a site, you actually might be interested in links to other parts of the site...? I'm totally confused about your quibble with brandchannel.
Re: facebook ads - maybe this will warn some girls away from putting up photos that would be tempting for a jailbaitgallery to lift. But as for the facebook brand--I think it's premissed on the idea of putting control into the hands of its users. Even though they're underpublicized, it has fairly detailed levels of privacy control and visibility that can be customized, which makes me think that it has a chance of surviving longer and being used by more people than past social networking sites like myspace and friendster.
If facebook disregards user concerns, which it sounds like they're doing...although not as blatantly as when they last(?) changed their site around (see brand guru John Tantillo's criticism of facebook for this here: blog.marketingdoctor.tv/.../...and-facebook.aspx), it could seriously hurt their brand--and shorten its life, or at least its uh...robustness.

October 2, 2009 08:09 AM #

chi U.A.E. says:

i think we know that everytime we join social networking sites whatever we upload soon becomes  public so we really need to be extra careful what photos and info we put in there...

October 4, 2009 01:00 AM #

jackson mutebi United Kingdom says:

more clarity is needed for proof that big social sites are misusing  people  information for their personal purpose i hope face-book is not in  wrong

October 11, 2009 07:00 PM #

payday loans United States says:

I like what I see. keep it going

November 26, 2009 05:51 PM #

payday loans United States says:

Yea nice Work !Laughing

November 30, 2009 04:05 PM #

loans United States says:

I like your blog but how do I subscribe?

December 10, 2009 04:15 AM #

payday loans United States says:

I like your blog but how do I subscribe?

December 15, 2009 05:56 PM #

club penguin cheats United States says:

There are literally tens of thousands of photos on sites like Fickr, posted without any copyright restrictions. While these images may not have any obvious financial value, site owners have to do more to educate users as to what "sharing" really means.

February 4, 2010 04:24 AM #

mma pound for pound fighting United States says:

Hello author, I've surfed the net more than three hours today, however, I haven't found such useful information like yours. Thanks a lot, it's really useful for me.

March 2, 2010 03:43 AM #

Comments are closed

What Branders are Saying on Twitter

elsewhere on brandchannel

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
brandcameoChronicle
An entire 'official' web existence is a Facebook page
Keeping KosherBaby Boomers
The New Disability Market
debateJoin the Debate
Nominate your #1 brand in 2011
BPBP
Back in Business
Jay DeutschJay Deutsch
The Super Bowl Ads Most Don’t See: How Merchandise Turns Raving Fans into Brand Champions
Digital Watch: WahlWahl Climbing
Assessing Wahl’s Digital Branding
Jeff Weedman
P&G's Jeff Weedman

Connect + Develop Your Career
Marketing to the New MajorityBranding 123
By Barry Silverstein