linked in facebook twitter rss

brands with balls

Red Sox Still Selling Disappointment

Posted by Anthony De Rosa on October 13, 2009 02:36 PM

Certain sports teams seem to cloak themselves in the warm blanket of lovable losers. The Chicago Cubs own that brand, but the Boston Red Sox, despite winning two rings in the past decade, seem unable to let go of their comfortable woobie.

After reeling off 95 wins this season, their playoffs ended with a thud with a sweep at the hand of the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim. Jonathan Papelbon, the Sons of Sam Horn's clown prince, raindanced away a 2-run lead in the deciding final game, giving up three runs in the ninth inning, and allowing the Angels to advance to the AL Championship Series.

While winning can fill a bandwagon, in some cases, like Red Sox Nation, losing can become a brand all its own. Despite having gone 101 years with no World Series win, and having the chance at one ruined in epic fashion, the Cubs still pack 'em in, with the sixth highest attendance in baseball last year. The Sox don't trail far behind, at eighth. Why do people keep coming back to have their hearts broken?

The Mets, who check in between the Cubs and Sox, with the seventh best attendance in baseball, are another one of those teams who always seem to be on the verge of turning the corner. In two straight years prior to this season, the Mets were rolling towards the playoffs before epic collapses, after coming within one game of going to the series in 2006. After a 2009 season with virtually no reedemable qualities, the Mets will have a tougher time selling that same idea that they're on the cusp of greatness.

While the Mets and Red Sox can try to claim some false sense of lovable loserdom, they're not being honest with themselves. Sure, the Mets have had their hearts broken in ways few fans can possibly imagine in recent years, but they've been to a World Series in the past decade, and they've won two in their history. There are Cubs fans who have gone entire lifetimes without seeing their beloved team reach the summit of baseball nirvana.

Being swept out of the playoffs seems to have jolted some Sox fans back to the post-traumatic sensation of prior years, before their embarrassment of riches. And like a emotional wound long since healed, they realize how much they missed how it hurts.

More about: , , , , ,

Comments

Sox Addict United States says:

Yeah.. no.

I don't "miss how much it hurts"; and it blows to be swept out of the playoffs, regardless of how recently you've won a championship.

October 13, 2009 03:11 PM # Reply

Katie United States says:

Maybe it's the company I keep but I see more Mets fans whining and wallowing in their self-pity than Cubs and Red Sox combined.  No one ever "misses how much it hurts" in sports.

I think the discussion that you're reaching at (in lines with branding) is how do the Cubs manage to keep up the attendance numbers with years of disappointment?  It's a club with years of tradition, and now they've built the idea of 'hope' into that tradition.

The Mets are going to have to go about it differently.  With a winning team across the river, they have to get rid of the 'disappointment' factor.  They need to get rid of that guys face who was all over the NY Post with the look that his dog just died because for the last 3 months, that has been their brand.

October 13, 2009 04:13 PM # Reply

Abe S United States says:

So. Much. Agreed. The Cubs are unique. I wrote a brandchannel profile of the Cubs years ago when they, like the Sox, made a run for the world series. My hypothesis was that they should lose if they knew what was good for their brand. I got hate mail; one guy wished me dead.
www.brandchannel.com/features_profile.asp

Over time I've thought more about it. I think "loser" teams like the Cubs and Sox benefit over time by building a fan base bound by "how much it hurts." But then that goes away when they win championships and the fanship is still there. Look at teams like Florida. They have a championship but not the longevity of unity to keep the brand strong. And there are other long suffering baseball teams that have nothing like the Cubs or the Sox in terms of brand championship.

October 13, 2009 08:00 PM # Reply

payday loans United States says:

Do you make money out of this blog? just curious

November 26, 2009 05:50 PM # Reply

Wii Fit Plus Principality of Monaco says:

I like this concept. I visited your blog for the first time and just been your fan. Keep posting as I am gonna come to read it everyday

February 1, 2010 08:42 AM # Reply

Add comment




  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



elsewhere on brandchannel

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
debateDoes social media have value?
Can Twitter, Facebook, and Foursquare really boost a brand's value?
brandcameoAlice In Wonderland
This film’s phantasmagorical landscape offers plenty of imagination, but zero brandcameos.
Wonder BreadWonder Bread
A slice-by-slice look at this storied American brand's website.
Bacon SaltBacon Salt
This tasty brand is spicing up new categories of artificial flavors.
paperThe Ultimate Marketing Alliance
How a unique union of market leaders cut market research costs in the shadow of the recession.
Gianine RothschildGianine Rothschild
An interview with the creative co-founder of Pookie, a lip balm and skin lotion brand.
Beyond Mad Men: It's Time for Brand SchoolBeyond Mad Men: It's Time for Brand School
Rex Whisman on Generation Y and the lessons the branding industry can learn from Mad Men.
All Customers Are Irrational All Customers Are Irrational
A marketing book about the human subconscious and how it makes us behave.
PaThe Networked Boomer WomanHeartbrake Hotels
Laura Fitch on Beijing's oversupply of high-end hotels.