Best Global Green Brands 2013

brand trainwrecks

Date Night With Stayfree? Er, No Thanks

Posted by Abe Sauer on August 31, 2010 05:30 PM

A while back we looked at how the popularity of the Old Spice guy had inspired not only spoofs, but also a genre of over-the-top absurdist ad messaging. Well, if you ever wondered how the Old Spice Guy genre ad could go so off the rails as to make you as uncomfortable as the original Old Spice ads made you laugh, we've got the campaign for you. Ladies and gentlemen, we present: "A Date with Stayfree."

The ads (the first in four years from Stayfree Canada) aim to "give women their very special chance to go on a 'virtual date' with three of the most perfect and sexiest bachelors we could find, who want nothing more than for her to be happy - no matter what time of the month it may be." The campaign consists of three spots and three "perfect" bachelors. Brad, Trevor and Ryan, take it away.

Is that tongue in cheek? Please tell us this is tongue in cheek. If the campaign is meant to be funny, it needs less tongue and more cheek. Do women want to mix dating with menstrual information? Does Stayfree believe its target market will find this funny?

As an online commentor named "Eww" noted, "Considering that I fall smack dab in the center of their desired demographic, I have to hope and pray that they failed to focus group the ad. I'd hate to think that a group of 18-35 year-old women watched this and gave their approval. This was stilted and uncomfortable to watch. Beyond the awkward presentation of the whole commercial, the idea of my date knowing that much about maxipads and commenting on how much he likes thinness is an incredible turnOFF!"

Comments

Robert Moss United States says:

This is less about the Old Spice Guy and more about The Brawny guy spots Fallon did several years ago. See www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELpBzFMVPFU&NR=1

Only Fallon artfully balanced sincerity and tongue-in-cheekness. These spots seem like some of the less enjoyable spoof spots on Saturday Night Live than something that'll actually get real people to buy real stuff.

August 31, 2010 06:42 PM #

WVM United States says:

I'm with you, Robert. First of all, these ads are a blatant (and poorly executed) rip-off of the Brawny online videos. Even down to the woman's pov-cam. The beauty of the Brawny vids and the site was, as you noted, in their balance of over-the-topness and subtlety. That character made sense - you got that he was strong and yet "always there for you," attributes that translated to the product. He didn't have to do any product demos. This Stayfree campaign is yet another example of laziness and theft in the ad industry. Instead of coming up with a unique idea befitting the product's brand promise, the ad guys said, "Hey, Brawny Guy worked and Old Spice Guy worked with our female target, so let's do something like that!" I find it a bit insulting to my gender as a whole. We women loves us some good, smart humor and if your brand can use it (and eye candy!) well to sell me on your product or service, more power to you. This isn't good, smart humor, though. And the eye candy? Enjoyable, but not persuasive.

September 7, 2010 01:40 PM #

Leslie United States says:

I think its actually pretty funny.  When did people start taking things so SERIOUSLY???!!  Its a clever way to demonstrate those 'pad tests' that have been on TV since the beginning of time ... Lighten up and take it for what it is - eye candy for women.

August 31, 2010 07:42 PM #

Robert Moss United States says:

You seem to be one of the few women who find it funny. But to answer your question, when did people start taking things so seriously, maybe because advertising along with making, distributing and selling pads (or any product) employs a lot of people, involves a lot of money and more is at stake than just making a few people laugh.

Don't get me wrong. Humor in advertising can be great. It can work when it's not making fun of its intended audience, and it can work best when it laughs at itself. But it doesn't work if it doesn't help sell.

September 1, 2010 01:26 PM #

Jen Canada says:

If women think it's OK for a man to buy them, shouldn't it be OK for a man to sell them too?  (especially men of this calibre)   Seriously though -- the point of a commercial is to get your attention and get people talking, and these three certainly get the job done.

September 1, 2010 12:45 AM #

Robert Moss United States says:

Really? "The point of a commercial is to get your attention and get people talking." If that's success then Summer's Eve produced the best ad of 2010, see
adweek.blogs.com/.../...douche-more-earn-more.html

I thought ads were to help sell stuff. Are people who own stock in Johnson & Johnson (StayFree's parent company) happy to just get your attention and people talking? Probably not.

September 1, 2010 01:40 PM #

Comments are closed

elsewhere on brandchannel

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
brandcameo2013 Product Placement Awards
Which brand is most bullish on Hollywood?
Coca-ColaIt's the Journey That Matters:
Coca-Cola Opens Up With Story-Based Web Refresh
debateJoin the Debate
What makes a great brand?
BPBP
Branding Comeback Challenges
Digital Watch: WahlAT&T
Rethinking Possible With Transmedia Storytelling
paperGlobal Competitive [Ad]vantage
The latest from GeoEdge
Sheryl Connelly
Sheryl Connelly

Meet Ford's Resident Futurist
Marketing to the New MajorityBranding 123
A primer by Barry Silverstein