2011 Product Placement Awards

rss

crowdsourcing

Crowdsourcing: Cheap Engagement, or Cheapening Brands?

Posted by Sheila Shayon on September 3, 2010 12:30 PM

Consumers are doing it for themselves — but designers and creatives don't have to quit their day jobs just yet. A checkered path of twists and turns has led to an unholy alliance: brands soliciting user-generated content, incentivizing users with prizes, and essentially doing an end run around agencies and specialists trained in the arts of creating and selling.

Has UGC run amok? Let's take a look at the latest fad in crowdsourcing: contests for product labels, as exemplified by Chiquita and Knorr, Unilever's largest brand, as MediaPost points out.

Chiquita's sticker design contest is inviting consumers to put their spin its 50-year-old iconic blue sticker. Narrowed to 50 finalists’ submissions, Chiquita fans are voting through September 12. Eighteen winners will be chosen and featured on bananas in November.

EatAChiquita.com has seen more than 500,000 visitors since the contest's October 2009 launch. Users create and post their versions of faces in the oval brand sticker, with some 25,000 faces were posted in the first six months.

Chiquita's Facebook page has almost 20,000 fans, many of them clamoring for their favorite stickers. And over at @ChiquitaChatter, 400 or so Twitter fans are doing the same.

The most committed fans can apply the stickers on their photos and posts, or “Shop A Peel” on Zazzle.com and buy products sporting those custom stickers. There’s also a "Banana Boogie Battle" video game.

The second example: Knorr Bouillon, a 100-year-old brand is soliciting consumer-generated content for its labels – in the form of recipes. Launched earlier this year, "Recetas Arrozísimas" targets Knorr's Latino consumer base of Hispanics – 50% of whom use Knorr in cooking four dishes daily from scratch, of which 14% are rice dishes.

The Spanish-language community site, KnorrSabor.com, received thousands of rice-centric recipes from which three semifinalists won $2,000 each and the opportunity for their faces to appear on Knorr's 2.2-pound bouillon jar labels. Their personal recipes will appear on on-cap stickers, in-store signage, danglers and flyers, as well as the website. A grand prize winner will receive $5,000.

"Recipes with Knorr products have been passed down from mother to daughter, from friend to friend — it is a multigenerational, everlasting tradition," comments Knorr Marketing Director Donna Barker.
     
"This has become more apparent with the explosion and growing influence of the Latino blogosphere — and our efforts, like Recetas Arrozísimas, are conducive to taking these conversations and recipe-sharing online."

With all the interest in crowdsourcing, it isn't suprising that ideation platforms like Salesforce Ideas and Lithium Ideas have attracted major brands like Dell, Starbucks and Best Buy.

As the practice grows – the question remains: does crowdsourcing, which is relatively cheap, cheapen a brand ... or expand it by putting it in the hands of customers? We'd love to hear your thoughts in our debate forum.

Comments

Emre Turkey says:

İ dont consider crowdsourcing as cheapening the brand. İt is a very good way to start conversation with customers and create emotional bond with them. Customers like the brands who care about their thoughts. Crowdsourcing platfom also lets people express themselves and show off their most creative sides

September 3, 2010 01:46 PM #

Shirley Brady United States says:

Thanks, Emre: appreciate your thoughts!

September 3, 2010 04:22 PM #

Brook Calverley United Kingdom says:

Maybe I'm getting old: but the concept behind crowd sourcing doesn't feel very novel to me (sticker design contests? Hello?)

Most UCG doesn't feel like a genuine attempt to reach out, either. And it certainly isn't a great strategy for unearthing brilliant new creative.

Rather, I suspect it's viewed by brand owners as an on-trend campaign mechanic that might create some cut-through while the idea is hot.

My guess is that it will pretty soon feel a bit 'last season': joining the ranks of viral, guerilla, SMS et al. It will have a place in the mix, but it's no panacea for brand engagement.  

Brook
@brookcalverley

September 3, 2010 03:20 PM #

Shirley Brady United States says:

Thanks, Brook!

And to anyone else interested in weighing in, please share your thoughts on crowdsourcing (pro, con or undecided) in our debate forum:

http://www.brandchannel.com/forum.asp?bd_id=133

September 3, 2010 06:43 PM #

Ahmad Abuljobain U.A.E. says:

Brook, I doubt you're getting older, just wiser. We're just getting fancier names for things that we've done for decades; and which just get done better with technology.

We used to put sampling stands in supermarkets; then someone came up with experiential (or shopper) marketing. Back in 1994, for example, we came up with a contest inviting viewers to write their ideal movie script and get it funded by a brand --- which would fall under the "crowdsourcing" nomenclature; but there was no YouTube or even email back then -- we ran an ad in the papers and people mailed in their scripts.

Brands haven't been cheapend by the concept -- whatever we call it. Participatory marketing has the potential to engage people; but sometimes the execution can be cheap or vulgar.

September 6, 2010 05:09 AM #

Escorts Australia says:

İ think crowdsourcing absolutely cheapens the brand. Emotional bonds with brands are created through thoughtful imagery, carefully tailored words and well executed campaigns.  And yes, actually having an outstanding product establishes the connection.  Crowdsourcing is the brand equivalent of reality television.  Instead of using creativity, it is dumping the brand on its audience hoping to find creativity in the consumer rather than the professionals.

September 5, 2010 12:14 AM #

S. Shayon says:

Escorts,
Love that analogy - crowdsourcing is the reality TV of branding!
Thanks for your comment.
S. Shayon

September 5, 2010 06:05 PM #

Ebel United States says:

Customers like the brands who care about their thoughts.

September 6, 2010 06:36 AM #

S. Shayon says:

Ebel,
So is there a way to combine crowdsourcing, i.e., - 'brands who care about customer's thoughts,' with expert acumen - hopefully derived from ad agencies - and get the best of both? A new breed of professional ads with UGC included - a "We Say - You Say"? Ad/Crowdverts? (We'd need to crowdsource a better name!) That kind of  format would actually be a...hybrid marketing conversation.
S. Shayon

September 6, 2010 10:04 AM #

Elizabeth United States says:

..."So is there a way to combine crowdsourcing, i.e., - 'brands who care about customer's thoughts,' with expert acumen "...

You bet! It has been done behind scenes forever, experts doing focus groups, interviews, surveys and then coming with great campaigns... now here, nobody is behind the glass, technology allows experts to be creative to undestand what is relevant about the brand, it is fast, multisensorial, consumers feel more free to say whatever... it is awesome!

Experts must know what consumers think (we all know that) ... what's wrong with having some fun with consumers participation??  Smile

September 6, 2010 10:57 AM #

Rori United States says:

I agree that crowdsourcing does not always need to be equated with consumer generated content. It can merely be about  'outsourcing' research and idea generation to customers. Vitamin Water is a great example - where consumers submitted ideas and voted on the best flavor, but ultimately the brand was responsible for the final choice and production. There is still a critical role for brands to produce and manage their own content - but all the better if the ideas are based upon feedback from the audience.

Crowdsourcing does not have to be a public effort, it can also be a private endeavor. Many companies have closed customer communities were they 'crowdsource' ideas without touting it to the world at large - and its very beneficial for R&D, marketing insights, and loyalty.

September 6, 2010 09:26 PM #

Comments are closed

What Branders are Saying on Twitter

elsewhere on brandchannel

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
brandcameoThe Grey
A tourism commercial for Alaska
Keeping KosherBaby Boomers
The New Disability Market
debateJoin the Debate
Nominate your #1 brand in 2011
BPBP
Back in Business
Michael StoneMichael Stone
Pan Am Lives
Digital Watch: WahlWahl Climbing
Assessing Wahl’s Digital Branding
paper2012 Social Marketing & New Media Predictions
A new white paper by Awareness, Inc.
Jeff Weedman
P&G's Jeff Weedman

Connect + Develop Your Career
Marketing to the New MajorityBranding 123
By Barry Silverstein