Interbrand IQ: The Best Asian Brands Issue

rss

auto motive

Chevy Volt Charges Past Nissan Leaf in America's Green-Car Derby

Posted by Dale Buss on July 16, 2012 12:52 PM

Pulling away at a "go" light, plug-in hybrids like the Chevrolet Volt have a big advantage over all-electric cars like the Nissan Leaf — because they have a gasoline engine on board that can provide the required performance punch.

That's sort of what is happening in sales of Volt versus Leaf as well. While the Chevrolet sold nearly 1,700 vehicles in June and, at 8,800, has more than tripled the number it sold last year, Nissan could only report sales of 535 Leafs in the U.S. last month. For the year to date, Leaf sold only about 3,400 units, down 19 percent from last year.

A Nissan spokeswoman told the Detroit News that the main reason for the decline in Leaf sales is that Nissan has been moving away from a "web-driven, build-to-order system that was designed to handle initial sales to more of a traditional dealer-based model."

As for Volt, "We're still trying to manage the production to demand," Chris Perry, Chevrolet's CMO, told brandchannel. "We still haven't totally filled the inventory needs growing in California and some other markets. We're still not sure how high is high with this product."

To be sure, GM fell far short last year of its initial objective of moving 10,000 Volts in 2011. But it has tapped into strong demand in California by outfitting a version of Volt to comply specifically with stiff emissions regulations in that state, which entitles drivers of those cars to move solo into the high-occupancy-vehicle lanes.

And while GM's production of Volt has been idled off-and-on this year, company executives continue to believe that, long-term, Volt is "a game-changer," as Perry put it. Future demand for plug-ins and all-electric vehicles remains murky, ever more so with gasoline prices moderating again.

But GM is confident that its huge investment in Volt, both in terms of a manufacturing commitment and as a subject of continued marketing resources, will pay off. For example, it doesn't plan to share Volt technology with Peugeot under the two companies' new partnership, figuring it's too essential.

So the company keeps backing Volt in new ways. It is airing its second TV ad for Volt in its emerging marketing of Australia, for instance. And now Chevrolet is pursuing the five million users of Recyclebank who earn points for educating themselves on green living and making green lifestyle choices, as Marketing Daily reports. The points can be exchanged for branded merchandise or donated to charities.

"We're going to keep using" Volt, Perry said, "as the brand builder that it is."

Comments

scottf200 United States says:

The opening comment is false for the Chevrolet Volt "because they have a gasoline engine on board that can provide the required performance punch".

Typical hybrids and most plugin hybrids (except Volt) will turn on the gas engine under hard acceleration or at modest MPH (<=62 typically).  The Volt is unique in that you can put the accelerator pedal to the floor and go up to the limited speed of 100 MPH.  It is purposefully designed to run on electricity/battery until it is depleted.

July 16, 2012 03:56 PM #

VoltOwner United States says:

I have driven my Volt over 12,000 miles. If you choose you can push a button and go into "Sport Mode" and you have gas electric generation combined with the battery for hard acceleration prior to battery depletion. By the way, I drove by gas stations for over 6 months and about 6,000 miles before putting in a drop of gas.
My wife and I are considering getting another Volt.

July 23, 2012 07:33 PM #

Sid United States says:

The first comment from scottf200 is right on target.  Big error by this writer.  Its clear from the beginning that this writer has no technical knowledge of how this car works.

As a matter of fact, pulling away from "go" lights is exactly where an electrically driven car is likely to outperform a gasoline powered car, because with electric motors, you can have max torque at 0 RPM.

I miss the days when automotive editors where technical writers first...

July 17, 2012 09:56 AM #

Nick Canada says:

I think another key obstacle for Nissan is the name. Who the hell wants to drive a Leaf?

July 17, 2012 12:29 PM #

Arik United States says:

Bottom line in my opinion is that the Leaf doesn't provide sufficient value.  As much as I like it, and I have test driven it and given it considerable thought, it really isn't a good value proposition.

While the vehicle is nice enough to drive and meets my basic transportation needs, the cost is much higher than "basic transportation" justifies.  Anyone who does the math can realize very quickly that the cost savings on gas during the lifetime of the car will never make up the difference between the leaf and a gas vehicle of comparable utility.

Now consider motivation for buying it - early adopters willing to pay extra for the novelty and put up with less range and the hassle of pure electric and/or those who are passionate about "going green" at any cost (and perhaps haven't weighed in the cost of battery manufacturing and disposal on the environment).

I would therefore propose that the Leaf is as much a "niche" vehicle as the Tesla's current offerings.  Just perhaps a less affluent one.

What could help Nissan?  The obvious answer is to lower the price of the vehicle significantly or improve the value in other ways - i.e. improve the range dramatically (the nominal 80-100 miles increased to 150 would be a good start).  I expect it is difficult to do this - I don't know what volume of manufacturing they would have to hit in order to be able to make a profit after making these changes.  I simply find it difficult to believe that there are enough folks (in the USA at least) willing to spend this much on a vehicle that is 'basic transportation' and has the current limitations of the Leaf just to "go green" - you aren't going to save any green in the process at the current prices.

July 17, 2012 08:52 PM #

Web United States says:

This writer lost any credibility with me two different ways:  By implying that the internal combustion engine drives the wheels of the VOLT at traffic lights, he indicates he knows nothing about the car.  The VOLT IC engine DOES assist with driving the wheels only at higher speeds under battery depletion conditions.

But the bigger falsehood is that the car is selling briskly in California. This is simply not the case.  Dealers have plenty of these cars right now.   A quick search of cars.com inventories within 30 miles of zip code 90001 shows over 280 of them sitting on Chevy dealer lots in SoCal.

They are not common sights on the roads of Southern California. I have seen about 20 of them since the car debuted in Dec 2010.   It is irresponsible to suggest this car is in high demand because it is not.

July 18, 2012 09:01 AM #

Blaine H Canada says:

I drove a Chevy Hybrid company truck, for the first time last month. Now I know it's not the same as the Volt, but I was amazed at how well it performed!! If I had the money I'd go out and buy one &  start saving money on fuel costs. BlaineH

July 21, 2012 09:56 AM #

Comments are closed

Brand Chatter on Twitter

elsewhere on brandchannel

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
brandcameo2013 Product Placement Awards
Which brand is most bullish on Hollywood?
Coca-ColaIt's the Journey That Matters:
Coca-Cola Opens Up With Story-Based Web Refresh
debateJoin the Debate
What makes a great brand?
BPBP
Branding Comeback Challenges
Denise Lee YohnLance Armstrong’s Brand
Denise Lee Yohn Weighs In
Digital Watch: WahlAT&T
Rethinking Possible With Transmedia Storytelling
paperGlobal Competitive [Ad]vantage
The latest from GeoEdge
Sheryl Connelly
Sheryl Connelly

Meet Ford's Resident Futurist
Marketing to the New MajorityBranding 123
A primer by Barry Silverstein