Interbrand IQ: The Best Asian Brands Issue

rss

personal brands

Boom Lowered on Lance Armstrong Brand With Damning USADA Report

Posted by Barry Silverstein on October 10, 2012 03:17 PM

What is it about the living legends of sports? These larger-than-life heroes -- people like Barry Bonds, Tiger Woods, and Lance Armstrong — should be symbols of lasting integrity, yet they often seem to self-destruct, shocking their fans and shaming their sport.

Still, these personalities' brands somehow weather the storm and they move on. Woods, publicly debased for his marital infidelities in late 2009, proved the point when he finally won a tournament late last year, the first since his 2009 Australian Masters victory. The situation with Lance Armstrong, however, plays by a different set of rules. The world's greatest cyclist was disgraced by doping charges that resulted in his being stripped of his seven Tour de France titles and banned for life from cycling. In August, Armstrong decided not to fight the charges, a move that many interpreted as admitting guilt without saying it.

Now, the boom is officially being lowered on Armstrong by the United States Anti-Doping Agency (USADA). The organization announced on October 10 that it is releasing its "Reasoned Decision" in the Lance Armstrong case (click here for a PDF). The USADA called it "the most sophisticated, professionalized and successful doping program that sport has ever seen."

The USADA evidence being submitted is in excess of 1000 pages and includes sworn testimony from 26 people, including 15 riders with direct knowledge of doping activities. "The evidence also includes direct documentary evidence including financial payments, emails, scientific data and laboratory test results that further prove the use, possession and distribution of performance enhancing drugs by Lance Armstrong," says the USADA in a statement on the "US Postal Service Pro Cycling Team doping conspiracy."

The USADA lists by name eleven teammates of Armstrong who it says came forward to testify. It will be difficult for Lance Armstrong to escape the damage this final judgment will cause to his brand. When Armstrong made his earlier decision not to contest the charges, he did gain the support of various corporate sponsors.

Brands that have supported Armstrong over the years include Anheuser-Busch, Nike, and Oakley; however, these sponsors pointedly said they would continue to support his cancer-fighting foundation, probably best known for its "Livestrong" brand, which appears on tens of millions of yellow bracelets and has spawned many marketing partnerships and a line of branded merchandise. The foundation celebrated its fifteenth anniversary recently with the launch of a limited edition line of apparel from Nike.

It's also a dark day, of course, for the embatteled U.S. Post Office (which sponsored the team from 1996  to 2004) and the subsequent title sponsor of the U.S. cycling team, Discovery Communications, not to mention the sport of cycling and the Tour de France. Loren Smith, former chief marketing officer for USPS, told the Wall Street Journal, "I think it was a very worthwhile sponsorship. It’s unfortunate that whatever has come out from it in the aftermath is carrying negative baggage and detracts from it." That said, in light of the USADA doping report, "If we had known about it, we would have ditched the whole program."

This brings the case against Armstrong to a close and, with it, comes the end of Armstrong's illustrious and unprecedented cycling career, even if he refuses to rebut the allegations that he not only doped but was responsible for a "doping culture" that has sulled his record, his former teammates' legacy, and the sport through which he rose to fame. His earning power as an athlete and brand ambassador will surely decline, but any lasting damage to his image will likely be buoyed, at least a little, by the good his foundation has done in raising awareness about cancer and other health issues.

Lisa Delpy Neirotti, a sports management professor at George Washington University, told USA Today in August, "[Armstrong's] goodwill — I don't think it will wane. There will be some disappointment, sure, but overall, if he keeps raising money for cancer research, it won't be an issue. ... We, as a society, have a short memory. It's old news now, when he performed, if he used drugs. People want to believe in their heroes." Of course, that's what she said before today's report.

Armstrong's PR team, website, Facebook or Twitter feeds have yet to release any statement or response, unlike his fellow former USPS cyclists, some of whom have been banned from competition as a result of the USADA action. Armstrong's Twitter bio, in fact, still reads: "Father of 5 amazing kids, 7-time Tour de France winner, full time cancer fighter, part time triathlete - LIVESTRONG!"

Your thoughts on how today's news will impact Armstrong's personal and philanthropic brands?

[Image: Brad Camembert / Shutterstock.com]

Comments

Gobsmacked United Kingdom says:

RIP Armstrong's reputation. I'm quite shocked that he has yet to release a statement, given that Hincapie and others are owning up to the doping allegations.

October 10, 2012 05:43 PM #

As the Crow Flies United States says:

I'm stunned and saddened. Like Jerry Sandusky, it looks like Armstrong will remain in denial that he cheated, lied and destroyed lives with his greed and need to win - at all costs, it seems.

October 10, 2012 08:48 PM #

Mick South Africa says:

Why not just have 2 categories of sport - Doped, and Straight.
Then see what falls out of the trees.

October 11, 2012 02:21 AM #

Shay Ireland says:

In light of the USADA report it will be interesting to see how his sponsors especially Nike & Oakley react. It will be difficult to continue supporting him, but Nike so make money from all the Livestrong merchandise.....
Lance mus think the public are fools, the longer he goes without admitting the more his reputation sinks. Think of all the non doping cyclists who had earnings robbed from them by the drug takers. Hope UCI drop their case against Paul Kimmage.

October 11, 2012 04:41 AM #

Ed Kriese United States says:

Liar, cheat, he's history...

October 11, 2012 12:09 PM #

pierce Canada says:

As damning as the cheating is, the most damaging thing to the Armstrong brand is the picture of him as a ringleader and a bully, pressuring his support riders to dope and aggressively pursuing those who tried to blow the whistle on the sport. It just doesn't fit with the philanthropist image he wants us to see. Without a contrite confession, his brand is doomed.

October 11, 2012 02:55 PM #

Jeremy CHW United States says:

Having read through all the USADA "evidence" which is basically his former racing colleagues' testimony, Armstrong was never caught red-handed so there's no absolute proof that he's guilty of doping. Whatever happened to innocent until PROVEN guilty?

October 12, 2012 10:25 AM #

JS Canada says:

Jeremy: "Absolute" proof is not required, just guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Problem for Lance is that everyone who could vouch for him seems to be on the other side. First he says hes' one of the few clean guys in the sport, now he's saying he's the only clean guy on the team he ran... incredible, don't you think?

October 14, 2012 10:23 PM #

Chrise Canada says:

I will never purchase any brands that support Lance again. This includes my colleagues. Emails have been sent his supporters. Yes, ths is a small statement but I can't support organizations in sport that consider cheating on such a grand scale is ok. Every time I purchase an item from another company I feel really good. I don't see that feeling ever going away. Put that in your brand analysis.

October 16, 2012 02:41 PM #

Comments are closed

Brand Chatter on Twitter

elsewhere on brandchannel

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
brandcameo2013 Product Placement Awards
Which brand is most bullish on Hollywood?
Coca-ColaIt's the Journey That Matters:
Coca-Cola Opens Up With Story-Based Web Refresh
debateJoin the Debate
What makes a great brand?
BPBP
Branding Comeback Challenges
Denise Lee YohnLance Armstrong’s Brand
Denise Lee Yohn Weighs In
Digital Watch: WahlAT&T
Rethinking Possible With Transmedia Storytelling
paperGlobal Competitive [Ad]vantage
The latest from GeoEdge
Sheryl Connelly
Sheryl Connelly

Meet Ford's Resident Futurist
Marketing to the New MajorityBranding 123
A primer by Barry Silverstein