linked in facebook twitter rss

  • Interbrand
  • Brandchannel

your chance!
your chance!
  Professional service branding: waste of time or sound investment?
 
 An individual is also a brand in his own right. Starting with a small outfit with family Name, one could expand his business beyond his immediate neighborhood. It would also help in franchising the business. Therefore branding is essential irrespective of a one-man band or a group of professionals. 
Zakir Ahmed, Business Development Manager, Electronics & Home Appl. - May 31, 2004
 
 When Pro-services Cos start to go up the value chain, it will be suicidal for them not to invest in Brand 
Pancham Endlaw, Chief Manager, Times Internet Limited - May 31, 2004
 
 Professional services firms have few lasting assets - one is the capability to attract the best people - because of their brand attributes! Try this without a name... 
Benjamin Gilgen, Partner, The Zurich Consulting Company - May 31, 2004
 
 Branding is essential for everyone, including pro services.

I specialize in marketing strategy development for high tech firms, and I make sure that is reflected everywhere. It illuminates specialization and differentiation, and puts me on client short lists during their discovery phase.

I also have a non-tech client in the language services business. They have strong market differentiators that are strategic to being accepted against larger competitors. Their brand statement and all our external communication reinforce their core brand. Without this, they would appear as a commodity provider, which is the kiss of death.

Branding doesn’t have to be expensive or time consuming. But it does have to be defined, and then reflected in all aspects of doing business. 

Guy Smith, Principle, Silicon Strategies Marketing - May 31, 2004
 
 The counterpoint reinforces the proposal.

In one-partner practices, the individual is the brand. As a practice grows, the company's values - and how they are expressed - have to reflect the joint personalities of all the partners.

Understanding and defining the internal values (ie. the service) and making it attractive and appealing (the brand identity) is the difference between mundane performance and a dynamic future-focused company.

In my experience, left alone to themselves, professionals 'speak' to their peers, rather than their prospects. Branding helps them understand the importance of language, design, markets, communication - and, most importantly, identifying service differences and living up to those promises. 

Mark Herring, Director, TALENT LAB Ltd (UK) - June 1, 2004
 
 Of course individual professionals are important to a professional service firm. However, an individual professional within a firm cannot provide a meaningful differentiator across the whole company. An individual's strengths won't necessarily align others to a common purpose and direction. An individual professional within a firm doesn't create a defined standard to attract, screen, and hire new talent. An individual doesn't create a platform from which the company moves forward. An individual can come and go, retire, fall from grace, or die.

A brand, however, can do the very things for a professional firm that an individual professional -- as important as he/she may be -- simply can't do alone. 

Daniel Green, Graphic Design Coordinator, Foth & Van Dyke - June 1, 2004
 
 I also had a high-tech B2B Client in the Ukraine recently; and brand strategy worked so well they reached their expansion plans 1 year early, and without any "growth desease".

In fact, services as ideas are subject to differentiation - here we also have a "battle of brands" as Jack Trout puts it. Brand strategy is also important in terms of corporate reputation everywhere, as PR-specialists put it. 

Alexei Sukhenko, Director, Trout&Partners/Russia - June 1, 2004
 
 Both research and evidence of business success demonstrate that those professional services companies who market themselves as successful brands grow their business faster than if they just rely on partners bringing in new business.

The real issue is how firms in this sector differentiate themselves from their competitors in an extremely cluttered marketplace. Greater client focus and achieving a higher profile through enhanced marketing communications. Marketing management who have worked exclusively for professional services companies can be guilty of producing 'much of the same' and there is a real need for fresh perspectives on professional services companies marketing strategies. 

Nick Handley, Managing Director, Marketing Leadership.co.uk - June 1, 2004
 
 Professional services are an area of expertise, and therefore difficult for evaluation and differentiation. That's why they need an interepreting in an everyday language. And the brand is the best means for doing this. 
Fanny Koleva, Doctoral student, University of national and world economy - June 2, 2004
 
 It’s going to be tough to find someone involved in brand building who will put forward a view that professional services should not invest in building their brands.

Thanks to Enron, et al, corporate branding, corporate social responsibility and corporate governance issues are rapidly gaining importance.

In the old days, professional services companies were able to trade off the reputations of their partners, in the same way that high tech companies trade off recent gadgets. However, this kind of promotion does not build meaningful or powerful associations for a brand among customers, investors or staff. The result? When the luster fades, either through a partner leaving or when a new gadget steals the limelight, people’s enthusiasm for the brand fades equally.

Furthermore, if a brand is only as strong as its star players’ reputations, customers will have very little leniency when things go wrong.

Still, trading off reputations is a good and necessary thing. But it must always be accompanied by a programme focused on building robust associations with the brand that go beyond the flash in the pan. 

Aaron Shields, Partner, Brandinstinct - June 4, 2004
 
 The firm's brand is extraordinarily important, and the firm's individuals literally are the brand. This fusion is extraordinarily important. The partners of the firm must know who they are, what they believe, and importantly, what they have in common and what they share. This mutuality of beliefs, identity, purpose and vision is what creates and sustains the brand.

Without this mutuality and a shared vision of the future, you don't have a business, and you don't have a brand. 

Ian Latham, Latham & Co. - June 4, 2004
 
 Few national or regional professional service brands in the UK demonstrate real brand differentiation or USPs in their marketing communications strategy. The global professional service brands seem much further down the road in terms of developing a distinct brand personality that is less reliant on strong individual personalities.

Professional service brands need to be bold to make their presence known in this increasingly saturated market where every player is offering 'added value' a 'commercial approach' and 'vast expertise.' 

Max Clark, Director, Marketecturegroup.co.uk - June 7, 2004
 
 Simple. Whichever or whoever has the best defined and most clearly communicated Brand wins. The client or potential client will go with the brand they feel they understand, know and trust. If the professional service is better branded--it gets and keeps the customer. If it's the individual, then clients will stick with him/her wherever they may be. 
MEL! Epstein, Brandologist, Who-What-Why Branding - June 7, 2004
 
 An unusual category: professionals are the bane of marketing communications pros because the value in any potential points of differentiation rarely goes beyond their success record. And typically their management is comprised of bean counters who don't want to spend money doing the hard work of creating a unique image. These are hardly the visionary leaders of learning organizations who understand the value of what branding can do internally (to build internal congruence within the organization's culture) as well as externally in potent communications.

Many professional firms grow by leaps and bounds without any discernible brand image or core cultural value to express. They are simply engaged for their talent and success record. The brand promise is purely capability - no mythology, no romance, no inspiration, no relationships to build or engagement to nurture. There are exceptions: the plastic surgery group who is SELLING image, the law firm AGGRESSIVELY PROMOTING to an audience whose needs are emotional, not commercial ("Wanna sue the pants off someone? Call Dewey Sruem andn Howe at 1 800 ...." And it's fascinating how the rest of their profession view these consumer-focused colleagues as hucksters and whores when they've merely determined a target audience and created a brand identity, coarse or crass as it may be. 

Jack Cuffari, Branding and Organizational Culture Consultant, Jack Cuffari Consulting Services - June 7, 2004
 
 The firm is clearly the dominant and most valued resource. Ask the individuals to try to get appointments and RFPs without the firm's brand and you'll go broke fairly quickly. People are obviously important AFTER you're in the consideration set. 
Jim Speros, Chief Marketing Officer, U.S., E&Y - June 7, 2004
 
 A basic principle of marketing 101, brands resonate in consumers'/ customers' minds. From the logo of a company to the people that are employeed there, these tools help build or destroy a brand. As a company, be it a service provider or supplier of a product, the tools mentioned above ( i.e. logo, icon or staff) are required to build a lasting, profitable brand, which consumers adore or customers champion. For top of mind awareness or for that matter to generate trial ( or whatever the marketing problems are) a comapny needs something that consumers or customers can identify with, without which, the company would be like a hill in some desert that bears no significance to one's well being.

For the succes of the brand all the facets of the organisation need to be well managed, and ensure that there is synergy ( internally & externally). 

Vuyisile Mzozoyana, Account Director, Lobedu Leo Burnett - June 8, 2004
 
 A bit of both is necessary. You need to spend time, effort and money to build and maintain a brand but the extent of this will depend on the market in which you operate. In a developed market a company’s profile is quite important, as the competition is immense. However, in a developing market, where resources are often limited, greater emphasis should be placed on the individuals as their talent and achievements form the basis of a company’s success. 
Panagiotis Zisis, Manager, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Greece - June 8, 2004
 
 Professional service branding; waste of time or sound investment. My experience tells me it's a careful blend of both strategies. We are a large NGO which has dramatically grown and internationalised in the last 4 yrs. We have done this by the careful mix of both corporate brand development and innovative repositioning but also growing our key staff to be able to win the confidence of our more significant customer representatives. As a result of this two prong approach our reputation has grown in parellel to the confidence of individual managers to approach new and larger international customers. 
Robert Doak, International Development Manager, Exemplas - June 8, 2004
 
 There are numerous examples of how successful branding a service firm can be, in particular if it is based on the expertise of an individual. This is also true in our own field of branding. Have a look at the Namedesigner and see for yourself how the personality of the expert stands for a humorous and creative brand 
Wolfgang Nedobity, CEO - June 8, 2004
 
 I think it's more subtle. The name of the professional service firm gets you in the door, but the individual keeps you there.

Given the choice of sticking with my lawyer or accountant or the firm (should they decide to leave and start their own practice), I'd choose the person over the firm any day. 

Customer - June 9, 2004
 
 I agree with the 'brand as being separate from individuals' argument, however, this is not always the case. What is Virgin without Richard Branson?

Professional Services companies can also build a brand (abeit a perhaps fragile strategy) around charismatic leaders or subject matter experts (McKinnsey & Co) but it's obviously more sustainable to not do that. Which brings me back to my observation.... actually what would happen to the Virgin brand without Richard Branson....hmmm. 

Greg Bartlett, Business Development, Hubbub Group - June 9, 2004
 
 My position on the issue is firmly in the middle of the spectrum. To a large extent, a professional services brand like Ernst & Young is a product of its people. The brand is the people who provide services to paying customers. But the brand is in the perception of the customers buying our services, so managing the brand is key, especially in today's turbulent, media-saturated market.

To illustrate how important it is to manage the brand, I'd ask a salesperson or partner in the firm to do a presentation to a multinational client without saying he/she is with Ernst & Young. Without the power of the name, he/she certainly wouldn't even get in the door. My point: brand management and client service go hand in hand. 

Peter, Strategist/Writer, Ernst & Young - June 10, 2004
 
 The employee walking away with the client is exactly what effective branding prevents. The idea that the individual carries the brand may be true, but the power of many people carrying the same brand experience has a far greater effect on customer loyalty.

The experience of a brand must be the same throughout an organization. Effective branding of an organization means that each member of the team understands the brand promise and carries out his or her responsibilities based on that promise.

If the only thing that motivates an individual is developing his or her personal brand it will do very little to develop a corporate brand and maintain customer loyalty to an organization.

A company that feels this is an effective way of maintaining their brand (letting the individual dictate the experience based on their own priorities) deserves what they get when an employee walks away and takes clients with them. 

Wes Campbell - June 11, 2004
 
 I don't see a difference between branding a product or branding a service. Albeit intangible, a service is still a product. No? With it comes emotions, customer service, advertising, PR... all the customer touch points you'd find in a typical, tangible brand or product scenario.

Virgin is a strong brand with a brilliant marketer at the helm but really, how many people at the consumer level know who Richard Branson is? Not many I suspect. That being said, the product or company name usually supersedes and is the banner or top-of-mind identification or reference for most. So, as per an earlier submission which stated, you would never get into the door if you weren't backed by a product or company name that built its equity/reputation with the consumer over time, stands true. Some people, like Richard Branson, or Michael Dell, or Bill Gates , as founders of their companies, whether they like it or not, whether they prefer it or not, have become brands within and/or apart from their respective companies/products. E.g. Bill Gates and Microsoft; Michael Dell and, well, DELL; Michael Eisen and Disney and so on...

In the end, the dynamics are quite common between the user and the marketer of a service or that of a brand/product. The main goal is to build customer base, retain customers and make a profit while you're at it.

Fedex is a service and a good one at that. They've spent millions on branding and they deliver a positive experience to consumers every time. Fedex has become a household name, a top-of-mind service for many around the world.

Google, in less than 5 years, has created a brand worth more than $2 billion -- this is a service and a free one at that. Take away the Google name and, well, you may lose everything that comes with it: reputation, accessibilty, reliability and the like.

Got a service? Brand it! Got a product/ Brand it. The only place you'll find some small differences is in B2C and B2B in terms of dynamics of targeted messaging, etc. 

Nicholas Di Cuia, Creative Director, Ferrand Communications Inc. - June 11, 2004
 
 I don't think this is an either/or situation. A company is because of its people, if you take the human factor out then all you are left with is office space, desks, computers, phones,etc. It is each individual's contribution that helps build the company no matter what it sells.

BRANDING plays a key role in standing out in the highly competitive and specialized world we live in. It not only establishes an individual identity of a company but also helps build recall and sustainabilty. 

Zain Yousof, Account Director, Evernew Concepts (Pakistan) - June 14, 2004
 
 Both points are valid as they are inextricably linked. The firm's brand should be driven by aligning the employee to it and creating brand ambassadors. True, a client's loyalty lies in part with their consultant, however if the brand is operationalised then it will thrive throughout the organisation and overtake individual personality power. In this way the firm's brand (effectively the collective personality) becomes more powerful than individual loyalties.

I think what we should be asking ourselves is not the utility of external brand building on a company scale but rather how you encourage employees to assimilate and live the brand. 

Nick Fowler, Producer, Marketing Week - June 14, 2004
 
 How does b2b brand buidling differ from b2c, what are the issues affecting b2b and how can these be resolved? 
Nick, Fowler, Centaur Holdings - June 14, 2004
 
 Having a brand with a unique style serves the service company well. I have done both. The branded service company sold more and lasted longer in the service industry.People move on. Most customers want services. Warren Buffet is a person. But his brands and services sold make him money for his investors. 
Ron Hansen, CEO, Ron Hansen.com - June 14, 2004
 
 Developing and nurturing professional service brands is important at any scale, whether it's a small local firm with no significant aspirations or a company with offices across the country or across the world. Reputation and image get you noticed and into the ballgame. That image could be of an individual who owns the firm or a person who represents it, both literally and figuratively. That image could also be of a global entity with numerous opportunities to provide professional services.

Brand identity establishes a personality, working style, or philosophical approach to the services being offered. That identity transcends the individual and goes into the service delivery and the outcomes of the client interactions -– building brand equity and loyalty.

Skipping around with individuals who service the business or represent the overall brand has been going on for a long time and will continue to do so. This happens because the individual or the client moves away from the brand’s direction/path and happens over a period of time or due to a major switch in that direction.

With that said, it is also important to invest in the individual who represent and are truly the pieces that make up your brand. It is also important to invest in your customers, not just depend on one person or small team of people to interact and conduct business with them. The more touch points and interaction with a broader swath of your brand, the more loyal and likely customers will not jump ship to a departing employee or a competitor.

Develop the brand to deliver on customer needs. Develop the individuals to deliver on customer needs. Develop the client to trust the brand to deliver on their needs. It’s a full circle approach that needs to be taken in developing a long-lasting brand, in any professional service category. Take care of the brand and the rest will follow.  

Jim Gann, Account Supervisor, Dalton Agency - June 14, 2004
 
 The survey results will be skewed. Respondents predictably have a 'vested interest' in branding. 
Helen Praeger - June 14, 2004
 
 Professional service branding: waste of time or sound investment?

The point – 'The firm’s brand is most important' and the counterpoint – 'Individuals are the brand' are both a key part of professional service company’s branding synergy.

The supposition is that the term 'branding' is best defined as an intangible benefit that significantly differentiates similar professional services in a customer relevant way. The discrete interaction or these two unique 'branding' parts is such that the total effect is greater than the sum of the individual effects. 

John P Hoeppner, CEO, NameQuest, Inc. - June 14, 2004
 
 Branding begins at home. From looks to deal to every service -- in everything the branding involves. So it's not true to debate about that branding occurs in the individual level or the corporate level. Corporations should build branding in such a way that every person should carry forward its identity wherever he moves. On a personal basis every employee will carry the same brand identity that should be completely mixed with their own identity.

Yah this is the tough job that every company or its steering committee members should perform to succeed in todays world. Client should not move with the consultant, rather he should stay with other consultants, because if somebody worked in the organization, he should carry the same identity. In that way u cannot differentiate between the consultants, u only consider the brand of the company as a whole. So the differentiation is immaterial. 

Shubhankar Palit, Sr. Officer Marketing, Kirloskar Ferrous Industries Ltd. - June 15, 2004
 
 Branding begins and ends with the entity that is on offer. Know the product offering, know the organization, then you will know the people behind it. That is one of the reasons why bastions of consulting such as The Boston Consulting Group have survived the erstwhile draconian policies and period of isolation that consulting firms went through.

Like Mr. gann very eloquently pointed out -- this is a full-circle philosophical approach that when executed with the proper tools can only bring recognition and not obscurity. 

Sanjeet Telang, Brand Consultant - June 15, 2004
 
 The people are the brand. I have no doubts about that. In the service industry the provider of the service cannot be seprated from the brand. They are one and the same.

I run a training and advertising consultancy, The Bigger Picture, and the fact that i am the brand is reinforced everyday. More so because I launched in January this year. The only reason that people give me appointments in the first place is because they know me, having worked in the advertising world ( Saatchi & Saatchi and a bank (Standard Chartered Bank). In fact right now I am bigger than the brand. If I fall short of what people expect of me (they already have a perception of me from their previous workings with me) my brand will be dead and buried before I can say the bigger picture. As time goes on the brand will be able to stand on its own. However it will not grow unless the people that I employ can deliver and keep clients satisfied.

In conclusuion when people are hiring consultants they hire the person, even if the cheque is written in the company's (brand's name). The people are more crucial the younger the company. 

Robert Wamai, Consultant, The Bigger Picture - June 15, 2004
 
 Stuff the brand! We're all out of a job then. There you have it. No professional cred, no brand, no job. What happened to Me Inc. hmmmm? Citizen 'brand' ... all that malarky. I must say, a decent parade of taste and values speaks miles for the way I'm going to place MY dollar given a professional services line up. 
Michelle Wigzell, Brand and Identity Schmuck, Me Inc. - June 15, 2004
 
 It is difficult to divide the two for success. Both are needed. To build a brand around the company and not have the individuals to support the promise leads to failure -- and an expensive one at that. On the other hand, individuals, no matter how good, cannot get further than immediate word of mouth and risk business if they choose to leave. To create growth, the company needs to build off its talent but go beyond individuals.

A good company invests in an overall culture that can withstand staff changes, and draws great talent. 

Paola Norambuena, Director of Marketing, Eventive Marketing - June 15, 2004
 
 After I did a major restructuring program for an org, i realised that THE PEOPLE MAKE OR BREAK A COMPANY; so there IS an obvious relationship with HR and CORPORATE BRANDING. Brands are about people -- PROfessionals both within & without. 
Millie, Director, Millicentcommunications Singapore - June 16, 2004
 
 A professional service firm needs to prove its mettle by actions, by delivering results and by performing better than others. This is what makes pro firms tick.

Anyway, which company will pay heavy bills to them? Most corporations today are tight on budget. They aren’t ready to bail pro firms’ ad expense. By the way, has anyone ever called a pro firm after coming across their ad? I bet you'll go to a friend or a colleague -- someone you believe can advise you better -- to decide on a pro firm. 

Sameer Gupta, Student, IIPM - June 16, 2004
 
 To effectively brand a professional service firm, you should incorporate both external branding (the point made in the sound investment category), as well as internally (the other point made). I do not view this as a yes or no question, but that people choose both the firm and the provider. 
Rhonda Rawl, President, Stratagem - June 16, 2004
 
 Saying brands are people or a set of specific services reflects a bit of internally focused hubris that disregards how people make product or service decisions. Few people will say they go to a particular accounting firm because they do good bookkeeping or to a consulting firm because they have lots of highly educated consultants. Those come under the heading of 'content' and are required just to compete. Customers talk about 'trust,' 'security,' 'confidence' and other emotional drivers that exceed basic content expectations that one has when going to a professional services firm.
Jon Stamell, President, Stamell & Associates - June 18, 2004
 
 Experience of law firms suggests it currently depends on the market. Consumers ask their friends for a recommendation and don't care less about a brand - they care about the person they deal with. Corporates are much more complicated, and often have multiple levels of contact within a law firm - unless a whole team walks, the client isn't likely to follow. As legal services become more and more commoditised the brand is growing in power and importance - most firms don't seem to have caught on to this yet. In the UK small to mid size firms are very likely to be hit hard when deregulation arrives, as service providers with strong brands are already preparing to enter the market. 
Andrew Young, Research Director - June 21, 2004
 
 Brand in the services industry are a kind of insurance for the decision maker. Nevertheless, brand it's also important depending on the "size" of the work you need. In fact, branded services companies are, at a first glance, more reliable for big tasks. In the opposite, indivuals with high profile could be better for smaller or more specific tasks. 
Luis Rosendo, Executive Manager, APAP - June 21, 2004
 
 It's absolutely essential that a professional services firm brand itself. Even if individuals withing the firm have the relationships with specific clients the firm, if clear on its purpose, will build a reputation that stands for very specific differentiating values -- that hopefully distinguish them from the pack. 
Steven Donaldson, President, Chief Strategist - June 21, 2004
 
 Marketing a professional service firm presents the unique challenge of branding an organization of service providers with different personalities and service styles. Revenue and business growth may be based primarily on the relationships between the professionals and their clients or prospects, however, like corporations, professional service firms benefit from a uniform internal and external face.

First, branding creates a perception of cohesion, team work and co-ordination. Fail to form these ideals in the minds of the buyer, and profitability will be affected. Another contribution of branding is that marketing and business development opportunities can occur in the absence of contact with a professional. The main contact point for all professional service firms is the client/prospect-professional interface. However, where the professional does not make the connection with a service buyer (there are only so many professionals to go around!), branding encourages buyers to investigate the firm and research the resources it can provide.

Getting regularly included on RFP recipient lists, or becoming known as “go to firm” for key service areas, are crucial results of a well-planned branding process. Creating these “passive” opportunities without direct contact with the potential buyer may not result in as much business as face-to-face interaction, but the increasing competitiveness in professional service industries makes this potential source of business hard to ignore.  

Ron Currie, Director of Marketing, Gowling Lafleur Henderson LLP - June 21, 2004
 
 This is a no-brainer… Professional Service Branding is everywhere whether you notice it or not. Real estate companies are the biggest users of professional or person branding. How many bus stop benches can you fit one guy's face on? (S)He’s selling him/herself and the ability to sell your home.

When it comes to the top valued employees they don’t push the company as much as they push the person. It can even be seen from Tiger Woods being the whiney little bitch that he is and complaining that the PGA is not giving him enough royalties from using him to sell the PGA, and then threatening to open his own tour.

Heskett, Jones, Loverman, Sasser, and Schlesinger came up with the 'Service-Profit Chain.' This is the concept that workplace design, employee rewards/recognition, etc, lead to internal service quality. This quality creates employee satisfaction. From this comes retention/productivity and then you become employer of choice attracting the best employees and keeping them. These experienced employees emanate the external service value to the customer, which obviously creates customer satisfaction. This will continue because of your great staff and you will see customer loyalty grow as well as revenue growth and profitability. These great results make those employees quite proud and happy and it feeds back into the internal service quality to continue the cycle.

Have you ever gone to a hotel and dealt with one long-time employee that knows exactly what you want and gives superior service every time? When that employee is not there any more…people notice. If there is a similar product/service right next door why do they continue to come to you?

Employee branding is important in so many ways. Of course the big drawback with playing your employees as your brand is your newly created brand jumping ship to the competition. If it’s a highly sensitive industry with customer list and such, it might not be a bad idea to sign some legal documentation that covers your butt as much as possible.

Professional branding…waste of time? I don’t think so. 

Ed Matthews, Student, Memorial Universtiy - June 21, 2004
 
 The intangibility of professional services requires a firm to become perceived as expert in its field. Strengthening the brand can be done through word-of-mouth, credible messages in promotion and PR, or investment in the consultants to deliver the brand promise and maintain the reputation -- all of these affect the brand perception of the audience. Where the professional service invests to strengthen the brand depends on where the gaps of service delivery or brand perception exist.

People do buy from people, but if the internal brand alignment of the services firm is solid, (i.e. if the internal brand delivery matches the external brand promise) the personable service will be associated with the firm. 

Zoe Flindle, Marketing Director, ThinkGroup - June 21, 2004
 
 Brand is important, but people seem to be trying to contort this catch-all idea into every situation. Reputation management and awareness are the key items on a professional services firm's marketing agenda. If this is what 'brand' means to you, then great. As I think most people would agree, however, there are big differences in marketing in an FMCG environment and in a Prof Services one. 
Chris Riley, Marketing Director - June 21, 2004
 
 We need both, they are like two faces of a coin, inseparable and incomplete without the other. 
Kaushik Sarkar, Account Manager, Response India Advertising - June 23, 2004
 
 Brand management is value management, both in the field of fast moving consumer goods and of professional services. But the approach to establish those brand values is completely different: Most marketing professionals in FMCG feel that the right advertising will do the job. If their counterparts in professional services believed the same, they would be doomed to failure. In their businesses, brand values can be brought to life by modelling culture, structures, processes and people according to the brand values.

So one of the clues to brand management in professional services is people. There is no real antagonism between investing in people and investing in the brand as long as those investments are in line with the brand values. 

Dr. Holger J. Schmidt, Managing Director, Monteverdi - June 23, 2004
 
 Reputation of the firm, the intellect and capabilities of employees and relationships with clients are the pillars that establish, support and press forward professional services' brands. If one of these pillars is removed, the professional service brand promise begins to wane. It is the distinct culture of these firms that allow the pillars to interact and to deliver exceptional performance.

Often professional services firms are partnerships -- meaning decisions are made by consensus -- no tolerance for individual grandstanding. Branding the company is a worthwhile endeavor and to the benefit of the firm name, employees and clients. Jim Speros' (see his post) comments are on point.

In the accounting and tax world, there are the Big Four -- after that it is a long, long way down to the next level (take no offense, please). Why such a huge gap? Perhaps the difference is brand and reputation management. 

Jean Avent, Student, Syracuse University - June 25, 2004
 
 The reason some people think it is unnecessary is because they expect branding of the professional services firm to be as "loud" as it is with an FMCG or such mass consumer product. This would be a mistake. Branding of a professional services company is essential, however branding elements and branding mix applied may vary. 
Asoya Ngozi, CEO, Myhappiday Communications - June 26, 2004
 
 The brand is central. For at least three reasons:

1) As good as the best service provider in the firm is, his income is a function of how much time he puts in on task. The smart service providers/individuals need the firm to make his/her business development efforts easier and faster. The right brand does that. The leading individual service providers know that and,

2) Add their own flavor to the context set by the brand. Obviously the brand value needs o be right and it needs to be flexible. But at the end of the day, the professionals will by design or inadvertently backfill in behind the brand. But that's part of energetic brand management in a service firm -- to outrun the service providers -- be in position to make them follow more often than they lead.

3) From the point of view of firm management, the brand not only cutivates the path of their hottest income producers, but raises the visibilty of that part of their overall enterprise. In turn making the management job easier and attacting more and similarly aligned and motivated talent.

Branding is after all a strategy that will outlast the short term self-intrests of the show-boating self-aggrandizer. Branding is not a mere tactical gap bridger -- that's what the money is for! 

Thomas M. Wiersma, President, The Verti-Mark Group, Inc - June 28, 2004
 
 I noticed no one here even talks about actual experience, except for those who really do work at a professional service firm. So it's all just mirroring the usual theory and rhetoric.

Our experience working in this field is that most professional service firms, no matter what their discipline, really have little idea about the power of their brand and are relunctant, particularly at CEO level, to spend the money required to make it distinguishable and valuable. We were recently invited to work with a top ten law firm in Australia that has a most undistinguished brand. They pulled the project because it wasn't important enough to get it across the line with all the partners. We had the same experienced at CGE&Y Australia. No real commitment because it equates with little understanding and appreciation at almost all levels in this country of the role of brand strategy and brands. 

Stephen Byrne, Director, DIFFUSION - June 28, 2004
 
 A firm is the habitat of resources.The professional finds expression through the firm. Clients feel at home meeting the professional through the firm. A strategically positioned firm which has its core competecies strongly articulated and backed by excellent deliveries of its offerings is an asset to both the clients and the professionals. Branding a service firm is branding the services and the professionals.Good people in a hole cannot be compared with fairly good people in a superb environment. The first get lost in the hole while the last get transformed by the right contacts and influences. However, it makes branding sense to go get the good guys from the hole before they lose touch with the good stuff they have in them.We should all answer this question: "What's in a name?" A professional is great because of the organization he represents.If he leaves, he begins branding himself and his professionalism afresh.It's all about a profoundly branded service firm with skilled professionals on board! Corporate Reputation Management clearly shows the way to go. 
ENO EKPO, COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING MANAGER, SKYWARD RESEARCH & CONSULTING LTD. ,LAGOS , NIGERIA - June 30, 2004
 
 
     
  back to debate